Pick-up at Munich Airport, 7:48 on a Tuesday morning. The Avis Preferred lane holds eighteen keys on a laminated card; the Avis President's Club strip sits at the top with the W-class saloons. The Hertz canopy next door has a Five Star priority bay and a longer President's Circle line beside it, with the keys called over a Tannoy. Same airport, two parallel programmes, and the choice between Avis President's Club vs Hertz President's Circle is usually treated as if the tiers were interchangeable. They are not.

The published rules diverge on the one thing that matters at a counter in a hurry: how reliably you drive off in a car bigger than the one you booked.

The quick answer: Avis President's Club vs Hertz President's Circle in 2027

Avis President's Club offers an availability-based two-class upgrade in North America on midsize-or-above bookings, plus a guaranteed car up to full-size with a confirmed 24-hour reservation. Hertz President's Circle grants a one-class upgrade when available and a broader location footprint. Business travellers who book midsize in North America usually extract more value from Avis. Leisure travellers who book intermediate at smaller US airports usually prefer Hertz.

What each tier actually gets you in 2027

The brochure language reads similarly. The written terms do not.

Avis President's Club: the two-class upgrade, with asterisks

Avis publishes two distinct upgrade mechanisms for President's Club members in North America. The first is a conditional two-class upgrade on midsize-or-above bookings, subject to availability and a list of class exclusions. The second is a guaranteed car up to full-size when the reservation is made at least twenty-four hours ahead. The two rules sit alongside each other in the Avis Preferred loyalty terms, with the guarantee working as a floor and the upgrade as a ceiling, so the car a member drives off in is whatever sits between them on the day. Priority service at most participating locations and a 50 per cent loyalty points bonus round out the package.

Outside North America, terms differ market by market. The European programme publishes a different upgrade matrix, Australia and New Zealand publish their own, and several Asian and Middle Eastern locations defer to franchise-owner rules that can be narrower still. A member landing at Paris Charles de Gaulle should not assume the North American rulebook applies, and the counter staff there will apply the local one regardless of which card sits in the Avis Preferred app.

Hertz President's Circle: the one-class guarantee and the Five Star gap

Hertz publishes a one-class upgrade for President's Circle members, subject to availability. The practical floor is a full-size car on a midsize reservation, when one exists on the lot. The loyalty points earn rate is 50 per cent above base, matching Avis. Where Hertz pulls ahead is the Five Star tier directly below, which creates a strange compression: at mid-tier US airports, the Five Star line is often empty and a card-granted Five Star driver reaches a comparable car to a President's Circle driver in roughly the same time. The incremental value of President's Circle at those locations is thinner than the headline suggests. At Miami, Dallas-Fort Worth and Newark the gap reopens, because President's Circle members get access to a separate Ultimate Choice lane and a wider vehicle selection.

Outside the US, Hertz's footprint thins faster than Avis's. In large European cities both brands operate. In second-city Europe, Southeast Asia and most of South America, Avis holds counters that Hertz has long since franchised out or closed. If the next three rentals in the diary are Lisbon, Krakow and Kuala Lumpur, Avis is the practical answer.

Where each programme is strongest in 2027

Three geographies decide the choice.

United States, business travel at major airports. Avis President's Club in a midsize-or-above booking tends to land a premium or luxury car when one exists. The two-class rule is the distinguishing feature. Hertz President's Circle in the same booking lands a full-size, which is a different car with different pricing in the published fleet.

United States, secondary airports and leisure stays. Hertz has more locations outside the big twelve airports. President's Circle at a mid-tier airport (Richmond, Boise, Albuquerque) collects the same one-class upgrade as a major hub, and the counter line is shorter than Avis's. The absolute car is often smaller than the Avis equivalent, but the time saved to the car can be larger.

Europe, Asia and the Middle East. Avis wins on counter density and on consistency. Published upgrade value drops because the local matrix is narrower, but the baseline experience (priority counter, named customer service, confirmed reservation honoured) holds at more cities. Hertz's international franchisees apply President's Circle inconsistently; some honour it as a formality, some do not recognise the tier at all. For a traveller doing four European rentals a year, Avis is the programme that behaves the same at each one.

Qualification: the earned cost of each tier

Neither tier is published as a straight purchase product by the operators themselves. Both sit at the top of multi-rung loyalty programmes with threshold-based qualification and a handful of fast-track routes.

  1. Avis President's Club: the published native threshold has historically been fifteen rentals or $5,000 in a calendar year, with the exact mix variable by region. Credit card status (certain premium issuer cards, including a route via Visa Infinite and some Mastercard World Elite cards) remains the cleanest route for members who rent under that volume. Avis has operated a status match to First tier (not President's Club) from major airline and hotel programmes; direct President's Club matches are not published routes.
  2. Hertz President's Circle: twenty rentals or $4,000 in eligible paid rentals, or a published status match from a selection of airline, hotel and competing car-rental programmes. The Amex Platinum partnership (Hertz Five Star, with a path to President's Circle after a qualification period) was restructured at the end of 2026 and requires re-enrolment under the new published rules.

For travellers whose rental volume sits below twelve a year, neither tier is naturally earnable in a single calendar year. That is the gap the direct-grant services were built to address.

Avis President's Club vs Hertz President's Circle, feature by feature

FeatureAvis President's ClubHertz President's Circle
Upgrade publishedTwo-class, midsize-or-above, availabilityOne-class, when available
Vehicle guaranteeUp to full-size, 24-hour advance reservation (NA)Reserved class honoured; no written upsize guarantee
Counter skipPreferred Select & Go at most participating sitesUltimate Choice or dedicated priority bay at larger US airports
Loyalty earn50% bonus on base points50% bonus on base points
Native qualificationHistorically ~15 rentals / $5,000; regional variation20 rentals / $4,000 (US)
International footprintBroad (Europe, APAC, MEA)Thinner outside US and large European cities
Status term12 months from qualification or grant12 months, with a lower return tier if volume drops

My verdict: which tier to carry in 2027

For a traveller whose next twelve rentals are split across the United States and Europe, Avis President's Club is the one I would hold first. The two-class rule earns its keep on the midsize-business bookings that typically make up the majority of a year's rentals, and the European baseline behaves more predictably than Hertz's franchisee patchwork. The $69 direct-grant route for twelve months costs less than a single dropped-vehicle incident on a Hertz reservation and roughly matches the cost of one US midsize day in high season.

For a US-only traveller renting predominantly at secondary airports (college towns, regional business hubs, the smaller leisure destinations), Hertz President's Circle still wins. The counter skip is more valuable than the one-class delta, the loyalty points earn is the same, and the app's self-service pickup at Ultimate Choice locations is a useful convenience when a flight lands late.

Travellers who want both are the minority who should consider holding each. A Hertz President's Circle card alongside Avis President's Club covers almost every airport worth caring about, and the annual cost through the direct-grant route sits below what two or three nights of a corporate rate used to add up to.

The LuxuryAscent direct-grant service for Avis President's Club

The reason this comparison exists, beyond the merits of each tier, is that most travellers who want President's Club will not reach the native threshold in a year. The direct-grant route exists to close that gap without a counter-side negotiation.

The LuxuryAscent Avis President's Club service lists at $69 for a 365-day term, with same-day processing and the published President's Club benefits applied to the member's existing Avis Preferred account. Benefits vary by market, class, location and availability; the North American two-class upgrade and the up-to-full-size guarantee apply where Avis's own terms apply. Verification of fulfilment, term and refund mechanics in writing before ordering is the standard advice, and remains the advice here. Members who already hold Preferred can carry the President's Club credentials on top of the existing account rather than opening a second one.

Readers comparing the Hertz option can see the earned-route breakdown in our Hertz President's Circle status guide, and the broader US car-rental elite picture in our National Executive Elite vs Hertz President's Circle verdict.

Frequently asked questions

Which is better overall, Avis President's Club or Hertz President's Circle?

For a mixed US and international rental pattern the Avis tier delivers more on paper, because the two-class upgrade and the up-to-full-size guarantee combine into a richer vehicle floor than Hertz's one-class rule. For a US-only renter at secondary airports, Hertz's counter skip and location coverage deliver more real-world value per rental.

Can a traveller hold both Avis President's Club and Hertz President's Circle?

Yes. The two programmes are independent and each tier applies to the operator's own reservations. Members who rent frequently enough to care about counter line length typically hold both, so that the fast counter at any given airport is always the one they are in.

Do Avis President's Club benefits apply in Europe and Asia?

Partly. The local upgrade matrix is narrower outside North America and the up-to-full-size vehicle guarantee is a North American rule. Priority counter service, the 50 per cent points bonus and named-member recognition carry across markets. Confirm the local terms before relying on a specific upgrade for a particular booking.

Does any credit card include Avis President's Club?

Certain premium issuer cards include Avis President's Club as a benefit, including routes via some Visa Infinite programmes and Mastercard World Elite partnerships. The eligible card list is market-specific and changes with each issuer renewal cycle. A traveller holding one of these cards should enrol through the issuer first before paying for a direct-grant route.

Is there a cheaper Avis tier that offers most of the benefit?

Avis Preferred Plus, the middle tier, retains the priority counter service and a narrower upgrade entitlement, at a lower qualification threshold. For renters who book full-size or premium by default, Preferred Plus closes much of the practical gap to President's Club at a fraction of the earned cost. The Preferred Plus route is the right answer for travellers who want recognition without the top-tier upgrade mechanics.

The bottom line

Both tiers are useful. The one worth carrying depends on the next twelve rentals in the diary, not on the headline benefit chart. Travellers whose next year includes European airports, business bookings at midsize-or-above, or a mix of the two should start with Avis President's Club and add Hertz only if the US rental footprint demands it. Travellers whose rental calendar sits almost entirely at US regional airports should carry Hertz first. Holding both costs less than most travellers assume and covers the entire realistic airport map.